Private vs Public: Perception vs Reality
— October 1, 2026Editor’s Note: A Three-Part Series on High School Athletics
This article is the first in a three-part series examining some of the most important issues facing high school athletics today. Drawing on more than four decades of experience as a high school coach and Executive Director of Edge Athletics, I will explore the public-versus-private school debate, the growing influence of NIL and the transfer portal on youth sports, and the increasingly complicated relationship between parents, athletes, and coaches. While these issues may appear separate, they share a common thread: how the changing landscape of athletics is affecting the opportunities, expectations, and experiences of young people.
By Jim Santoro
Executive Director, Edge Athletics
Rethinking the “Unfair Advantage” Narrative in High School Athletics
For more than four decades, I have worked with student-athletes throughout the Hudson Valley as a high school coach, youth coach, and Executive Director of Edge Athletics. During that time, I have had the opportunity to coach and mentor players from public schools, private schools, large districts, small districts, urban programs, and suburban programs. That experience has given me a unique perspective on a debate that continues to gain momentum across New York State: whether private schools possess an unfair advantage over public schools.
As someone who works with athletes from multiple communities and school systems, I understand why the question is being asked. Competitive balance matters. Fairness matters. Every student-athlete deserves an opportunity to compete on a level playing field. But after spending decades developing players from every type of educational setting, I have come to believe that the conversation is often framed too narrowly.
The assumption that success can be explained primarily by school classification, geography, or enrollment type overlooks the countless other factors that influence athletic achievement. Coaching matters. Culture matters. Commitment matters. Player development matters. Those realities exist regardless of whether a school is public or private.
One of the most common criticisms directed toward private schools is the belief that they recruit athletes. Certainly, there are programs throughout the state that have drawn scrutiny for their recruiting practices. But broad assumptions about entire categories of schools can be misleading. Programs should be judged by what they actually do, not by what people assume they do.
That same principle applies to public schools. Over the years there have been well-documented examples of residency disputes, transfer controversies, and creative interpretations of enrollment rules within public school systems. Yet no one suggests that every public school should be judged by the actions of a few. The same standard should apply to private schools.
Because of my role with Edge Athletics, I also understand that some people naturally connect AAU basketball and player development programs to the recruiting conversation. It is a fair question, and one that deserves a direct answer.
Edge Athletics serves athletes from multiple school districts throughout the region. Most of those athletes attend public schools. Many eventually compete against one another during the high school season. Our responsibility is not to influence where athletes attend school. Our responsibility is to help them improve.
Families make their own educational decisions based on academics, values, location, finances, school culture, and a variety of other factors. Development is not the same as placement, and exposure is not the same as influence. In fact, one of the most consistent messages we share with athletes is that long-term growth matters far more than short-term visibility.
Another argument often raised is that private schools can draw from a broader geographic area than public schools. Historically, there was some truth to that distinction. Today, however, the landscape has evolved considerably. Some public school districts now offer nonresident tuition programs that allow students to attend schools outside their home districts. While these programs may have enrollment limitations, the impact on competitive balance cannot always be measured by percentages alone. In basketball, a team does not need a large number of incoming players to significantly change its competitive outlook. Two or three high-level players can make an enormous difference. That does not mean these programs are being used to recruit athletes, but it does mean the traditional argument that public schools are strictly limited by geographic boundaries is no longer universally accurate.
At the same time, public schools possess another advantage that is rarely discussed: continuity in player development. When talented athletes reside within a district and attend their local public school, that school benefits without having to attract them from elsewhere. Many public schools also have established feeder systems, including modified school teams and, in some communities, school-affiliated AAU programs that begin developing players years before they reach the varsity level. Through these programs, young athletes become familiar with the coaching philosophy, terminology, expectations, and culture of the high school program they will eventually represent. By the time they reach varsity basketball, some have already spent years developing within that system.
Even within that broader discussion, it is important to recognize how most successful programs are actually built. Very few teams are composed entirely of elite athletes. Most rosters consist of a handful of standout players surrounded by teammates who embrace roles, improve over time, and contribute to a larger system. Development remains the foundation.
Private and parochial schools operate differently, and the assumption that families choose these schools primarily for athletics is not supported by the broader research on school choice. Studies conducted by the U.S. Department of Education and independent education researchers consistently identify academic quality, school safety, religious or moral values, and the overall educational environment as important reasons families choose private education. Athletics may influence some families, just as it can influence families choosing among public schools, but it is a mistake to portray private and parochial schools as athletic pipelines when their primary purpose is education. For most families, the decision involves far more than where their children might play basketball. 2024 EdChoice survey | U.S. Department of Education’s school-choice research
There is also an irony in this debate that rarely gets discussed. For generations, Catholic parishes and parochial schools have helped provide organized basketball opportunities through the Catholic Youth Organization (CYO), often beginning in elementary school. These programs introduce young athletes to the game, providing coaching, competition, and opportunities to develop their skills long before they reach high school. And who benefits from that development? Certainly not just Catholic or private schools. Many of those same youngsters eventually attend public high schools, where they become contributors to their basketball programs. In effect, the Catholic school and parish community has helped provide a foundation for the development of athletes who ultimately compete for public schools, including against the very private schools now being accused of having an unfair advantage. These programs exist to give young people opportunities to play, learn, and grow—not to serve as recruiting pipelines into private education. It is worth remembering that the Catholic school and parish community isn’t simply benefiting from youth basketball development—it has spent generations helping provide those opportunities to children throughout the community, regardless of where they eventually attend high school.
Throughout my coaching career, I have repeatedly watched teams exceed expectations because of preparation, chemistry, discipline, and belief. Some of the most memorable teams I have coached were not considered favorites. They were underdogs. Yet they found ways to compete against higher-ranked opponents, future college players, and even future professionals.
Those experiences reinforced a lesson that every coach eventually learns: talent matters, but talent alone does not determine outcomes.
Another factor frequently missing from this conversation is classification. Across New York State, successful programs can be moved into higher classifications based on competitive performance. In some cases, schools with relatively small enrollments regularly compete against schools with significantly larger student populations and deeper talent pools. Success often results in additional challenges rather than additional advantages.
It is important to acknowledge that no system is perfect. There are programs—public and private—that push the boundaries of the rules. That reality contributes to perceptions of imbalance. But broad assumptions about entire categories of schools are rarely productive. What matters most is consistent standards and consistent enforcement.
That principle has become increasingly important because the debate is no longer theoretical. It is now shaping policy decisions across New York State.
In June of 2026, Section 1 member schools voted overwhelmingly, by a margin of 69-4, to amend their constitution and separate non-public schools from public schools in postseason competition beginning with the 2027-28 school year. Under that proposal, private schools would compete for separate sectional championships but would lose the opportunity to advance to New York State championship competition. The vote was particularly revealing because the four private schools affected opposed the amendment, while the overwhelming support came from public schools.
But the story did not end there. Three private schools—The Ursuline School, Albertus Magnus High School, and Keio Academy—appealed the decision to the New York State Public High School Athletic Association. In July 2026, a three-member NYSPHSAA appeals panel unanimously overturned the amendment, concluding that Section 1 had exceeded its authority under the association’s constitution. Ursuline announcement
I believe that ruling was significant, not simply because it preserved championship opportunities for private-school athletes, but because it reinforced an important principle: decisions affecting the eligibility and opportunities of student-athletes must be governed by consistent rules, not simply by the will of the majority. Competitive balance is a legitimate concern, but excluding an entire category of schools is not necessarily the answer.
The NYSPHSAA has already taken steps to address competitive balance through statewide classification criteria for schools without geographic boundaries, including private and parochial institutions. Those provisions allow successful programs to be moved into higher classifications rather than being excluded from championship competition altogether.
What troubles me most about the original Section 1 proposal is what it would have meant for the athletes themselves. Imagine a student-athlete who spends four years working toward a championship, commits countless hours to practices and training, sacrifices for teammates, and ultimately earns a sectional title—only to be told that the opportunity to compete for a state championship ends there because of the school they attend. Those athletes did not create the rules or the circumstances being debated. Yet they would have been the ones paying the price.
The state ruling prevented that outcome under the Section 1 amendment, but it did not eliminate the underlying debate. There are legitimate concerns about competitive balance, and those concerns deserve attention. But there are also significant differences among private schools. Some operate under NYSPHSAA rules, do not recruit athletes, and do not offer athletic scholarships, while others may operate under very different models. Treating them all as though they possess the same advantages ignores those differences and risks creating new inequities in the name of fairness.
If fairness is truly the goal, then the focus should remain on consistent standards, consistent enforcement, and accountability for programs that violate the rules—regardless of whether they are public or private. Programs should be evaluated based on how they operate, not simply by the category in which they fall.
Because in the end, success in high school athletics is rarely about structure alone. It is the result of preparation, commitment, and the culture within a program.
And those things still have to be earned.
Coming Next in Part 2:
What We’re Losing in the New Era of College Sports
